Welcome to MelvinBlog Dot Com. Check out the best posts from the blog and subscribe to my feed.

MelvinBlog’s Best Blog Marketing Tip Contest

Posted on May 31, 2010 by Melvin

Update: This contest has been extended up to July 25. For more info, read here:

It has finally come. Today I am bringing you probably the largest contest in the history of MelvinBlog Dot Com. This contest commemorates the second year of this blog (funny how I thought its 3 years) and as I’ve planned, we’ll celebrate it with a big bang!

I have been preparing this contest since early last month and I want to make sure that my contest is going to be different. Different in the sense that first, it will add a HUGE value to the blogosphere and second, that every blogger, big or small has an equal chance of winning. I’m very proud to have had this contest finally polished.

Introducing the MelvinBlog’s Best Blog Marketing Tip Contest

Best Blog Contest

This contest says it all. The contest will be about blog marketing which is part of what this blog tackles on an everyday basis. The idea of the contest came after I witnessed (and won) the same type of contest held by Market Leverage w/c is entitled Affiliate Marketing  Secrets Contest. I’d like to first and foremost thank and introduce to you guys my media partner slash sponsor for this one. It is Fergal Crawley of the Business Advice Forum who will be handling all the promotions and stuffs for this contest. By the way Business Advice Forum is a good community forum giving out free business advice both to online and offline business forums. Its a nice forum so I highly suggest for you to check it out.

And to the sponsors. I can’t believe we were able to get this much prize for the contest. Compared to last year’s contest, we basically doubled the amount of the prizes and Im really thankful for the sponsors for that. As you know me, I just don’t get every Dick and Harry as sponsors. We got reputable and popular internet marketers as well as established companies that backed us up in this contest and again I’m giving them my biggest appreciation for helping out.

Sponsors

Gold Sponsors

  • QuickSprout – Quicksprout is a blog about entrepreneurship and personal branding. It’s owned by a very successful entrepreneur Neil Patel who owns various software companies and also does consulting for big companies like TechCrunch and etc.
  • LogoNerds - LogoNerds is custom logo design company that offers high quality custom designs, impeccable service and unbeatable prices, LogoNerds.com has quickly become the number one choice of small businesses everywhere.
  • Shoutmeloud - ShoutmeLoud is a blog tackling blogging and technology and is owned by Harsh Agrawal. It is one of the most popular blogs here in Asia and is amazingly getting good rankings on search engines. He also offers a Blogger to WordPress migration service
  • Themewars -  Themewars is a premium themes club owned by the ever popular Unique Blog Designs who have made the designs for a lot of popular bloggers in the industry.
  • Carl Ocab – more famously known as KidBlogger, Carl is a turning 16-year old kid who probably has made more money than you. At that young age, he was able to fund several product oriented sites like the Ultimate Blogging Theme and YoungestBloggers.
  • MyBlogGuest - MyBlogGuest is a serviceable forum aimed finding guest bloggers and blogs to guest blog. It is managed by SEO specialist Ann Smarty.

Silver Sponsors

  • SmartBloggerz – SmartBloggerz provides useful tips for bloggers about making money online, blogging, SEO and etc.
  • DailyBlogTips - DBT is a very popular blog when it comes to blogging and it is considered as one of the market leaders in the blogging niche.
  • OIO Publisher – OIOpublisher is an ad manager that focuses on maximising your revenue, saving you time, and keeping you in complete control of your ad space.
  • Blogussion – Blogussion is a blog handing out blogging tips and timely discussions all about improving blogs. They are a blog about blog­ging that pro­vides out­stand­ing tips for excelling your blog in a vari­ety of top­ics.
  • GabFire Themes – Gabfire Themes was founded in 2008 by Mehmet Özekinci a 29-year old independent web designer and web project consultant based in Estonia.
  • Dean Hunt – The ever popular Dean Hunt is the pioneer of Buzz and Personality Marketing. He runs a very popular blog at DeanHunt.com w/c gives out the best buzz marketing strategies on the internet.

Bronze Sponsors

  • WebTrafficROI – WebTrafficROI is a web marketing blog aimed at people passionate about their Web Business and Blogging.
  • Jimvesting – JimVesting is a blog owned by Jim Regan. The blog gives out stock market tips, business advices, and making money online in  general.
  • Blogtactic - is a blog owned by Richard about making money online targeted more to Malaysia.
  • FamousBloggers - Famous Bloggers is a multi-authors blog and Social Network platform for Making Money Online Tips built on the contributions of its authors.
  • Elegant Themes – Elegant Themes is an all access WordPress themes membership site that provides the best themes on the market. It also offers exceptional support through forums.
  • BetterBloggingForBloggers – BBB is ran by Liane who is one of the few talented young bloggers in the industry. The blog provides blogging tips aimed both for newbie and experts.

Contest Mechanics

So this contest like I’ve said is a creative writing contest. In order to gain an entry, the blogger/contestant has to write a blog post on his blog about his best blog marketing tip. That certain blog post accounts for 1 entry. Each blogger can submit up to 5 entries all throughout the duration of the contest. There is no rule aside from that the post has to be original, must never have been copied somewhere.

Each entry has to link back to this contest post so I can track all the entries. The link bank can either be in the beginning or at the end of the post. To be uniform with everyone,  you can just copy and paste this line:

This post is an entry to MelvinBlog’s Best Blog Marketing Tip contest where there are $2000 worth of prizes at stake.

There will be 3 winners overall and they are gonna get determined by two factors: quality of posts, and popularity. In terms of quality, I have hired 4 judges who are gonna gracefully judge all the entries. I really like to disclose their names but I was told its better not to. Popularity on the other hand, is just about the no.of retweets and comments. So to increase  your entries’ popularity, you have to at least give maximum exposure to it (letting it in front for more days means better). Lastly, the criteria is 70 to 30, the higher one goes for quality while the latter is for the popularity.

The popularity factor which is 30%  hinges on few metrics which include the no.of retweets of that certain post and amount of comments. I’d like to point out that the popularity criteria is just 30% because I want to give a fair chance of winning especially to those smaller bloggers.

Just for this mechanics alone, I have created a sample entry located of course on my personal blog. (this is just a sample). You can use it as a reference.

Prizes

A little side note: Like in the previous year’s contest, I don’t want to boast just the value of the prizes based on its financial worth. I’m sure there are a lot of eBooks out there thrown for $1000 and by giving 5 copies, it would already be $5000 worth of prizes in a contest, lols. Fortunately, this is not. Like last year, I tried to gather the best prizes from the best people in this space. So just by looking on who they are you will know what I mean. ;-)

1st Place – Total at stake = $877

  • 6 months free for the standard package of CrazyEgg valued at $19 a month – $114 value
  • 1 character design courtesy of LogoNerds – $97 value
  • 1 multi-use package of Themewars premium theme -  $70 value
  • WordPress SEO service courtesy of ShoutMeLoud.com – $250 value
  • 1 First Class Package of Ultimate Blogging Theme 3.0 – $147 value
  • 1 license of OIO Publisher – $47 value
  • $20 cash from FamousBloggers.com – $20
  • 6 months free Web hosting courtesy of MelvinBlog.com – $45 value
  • 1 copy of Killer Domains eBook by Daniel Scocco – $17 value
  • Premium Interview featured here in MelvinBlog.com – $70 value

2nd Place – Total at stake = $504

3rd Place – $302

  • 1 copy of Gab Fire Theme – $59 value
  • 1 year membership for ElegantThemes -$19
  • $15 cash, one advertising space and one copy of Facebook ad coupon eBook valued at $15 courtesy of Smartbloggerz.com – $54 total value
  • 1 copy of  Easy Blog Traffic worth $59, Insider SEO Revealed at $39 and Twitter Marketing Power worth $57 courtesy of WebTrafficROI.com
  • 1 copy of Thirtyday blog eBook by Jimvesting – $15 value
  • 1 copy of 70 Posting Ideas courtesy of Liane – $15

Retweet Contest

Due to some demands and also taking this advice from some of my blogger friends’, I would be running a totally separate contest on Twitter which is all about marketing this contest through Twitter. So in order to enter the retweet contest all you have to do is retweet this post using the tweetmeme button above or copying this text and pasting it directly to your twitter:

“RT @melvinblog, Best Blog Marketing Contest, win over $2000+ in REAL prizes http://bit.ly/bestblogcontest pls RT “

You can modify the text or do it your own way, just make sure you append the @melvinblog reply so I can easily track all the entries. This small contest would run the same as the main contest and would end after one and a half months so do keep on tweeting. At the end of the duration, 10 lucky entries will be drawn and will receive each of the following:

Some Secret Contests

To add another layer of excitement (or confusion, whichever you prefer), I’d like to include some other contests that may go live along the way. Not really secret, but more of short contests within the main contests, that can make this whole thing more exciting and the best is that it gives more opportunity for the participants to win.

So lets say, you don’t have a tip. Still you can join the retweet contest and some secret contests that I am going to throw as well. So what’s the best way not to miss these other exciting hidden contests? Well make sure you’re subscribed to the blog, so you don’t miss anything out. ;-)

Duration & Other Rules

The contest would run for one a half months and it will end on July 15th 12 am ET. After that date, no more entries will get accepted so make sure you start working on your entries right now. Also please give us 5-7 days max to compute all the stats and  announce the winners (patience is virtue my friend).

Questions, Clarifications, Suggestions?

No contest is perfect, most are faulty especially at the start. If you have anything to ask, clarify, suggest or criticize, feel free to do so in the comment form. Remember that good contests are good not mainly because of the prizes, but also with the participation from the audience like you. ;-)

I will reserve this space for other rules which I dont have at the moment. But Im sure this comment box will get populated as soon as possible. And that would only be probable, if you start asking questions now. ;-)

Note: An update and clarification on contest was published here. It also contains the official FAQ

Popularity: 15% [?]

Share and Enjoy:
  • Digg
  • Sphinn
  • del.icio.us
  • Facebook
  • Mixx
  • Google Bookmarks
  • Reddit
  • BarraPunto
  • StumbleUpon
  • Technorati
  • Fark
  • NewsVine
  • Suggest to Techmeme via Twitter
If you enjoyed this post, make sure you subscribe to my RSS feed!
    Related Posts
  • MelvinBlog’s Marketing Tip Contest Winners...
  • $2000 Blog Marketing Contest Recap & Announcements...
  • Best Blog Marketing Tip Contest Updates & Clarifications...
    71 comments so far (is that a lot?)

    71 Responses... What Say You?

    1. Awesome contest and hell lot of prizes. I am in. Best of Luck as well. Just made the tweet.
      Agent Deepak | Blogging, Marketing & Success´s last blog ..5 Awesome Anti Spam Plugins You Should Install on Your Blog My ComLuv Profile

      Reply

    2. Justin Dupre

      - 1st Jun, 10 12:06pm

      Thanks for the tip and the awesome list of sponsors. There are so many cool prizes out there for us!

      Reply

    3. Dev | Technshare

      - 1st Jun, 10 05:06pm

      Wow. Awesome contest man and prizes are really great :) . Count me In.
      Just Retweeted. Thanks.
      Dev | Technshare´s last blog ..How to be an Effective Blogger? My ComLuv Profile

      Reply

    4. Cebu Tech Blogger

      - 1st Jun, 10 07:06pm

      $2000 worth of prizes??? Wew… That’s definitely awesome, man… Hopefully I can join this…
      Cebu Tech Blogger´s last blog ..If there’s an iPad, there’s iPed! My ComLuv Profile

      Reply

    5. Ajith Edassery

      - 2nd Jun, 10 03:06pm

      Awesome contest man… good luck to all participants. I shall try to participate..
      Ajith Edassery´s last blog ..Blog readability test – How readable is your blog? My ComLuv Profile

      Reply

    6. Melvin (author comment)

      - 2nd Jun, 10 05:06pm

      hey guys. Im expecting your participation. ;-) Uhm, if you happened to have any questions or you’re doubting something, use this comment form so we can discuss it and make this contest the perfect contest.

      Reply

    7. Liane

      - 2nd Jun, 10 06:06pm

      Great! So it’s now live. Will try to promote it. Goodluck Melvin!

      and and and, I wanna win! hahaha
      Liane´s last blog ..Who Subscribes to the Better Blogging For Bloggers Newsletter? My ComLuv Profile

      Reply

    8. constantskeptic

      - 3rd Jun, 10 12:06am

      hmm. great way to get more views to your blog, get others to add links for you on their blog and offer ‘prizes’. what a bunch of crap. i hope you moderate this so you can dupe as many people as possible. you might as well just run a ‘free ipad’ contest, would be the same thing. best of luck to you.

      Reply

      Melvin Reply:

      thanks.i don’t need to block this comment. if you feel im tricking people, then i feel unfortunate for you my dear. :(

      Reply

    9. Jimvesting

      - 3rd Jun, 10 12:06pm

      Awesome contest, I’m glad it came together with such success!
      Jimvesting´s last blog ..Choosing The Right Web Hosting Package For Your Blog My ComLuv Profile

      Reply

    10. Murlu

      - 3rd Jun, 10 01:06pm

      You can count me in :)

      I’ll be working hard to promote (and win!) – lots of great prizes, I’m up for some friendly competition hehe
      Murlu´s last blog ..5 Best Benefits Of Working Online My ComLuv Profile

      Reply

    11. Chris Guthrie

      - 3rd Jun, 10 02:06pm

      If I give you a $10 gift card to Bed Bath and Beyond can you set me up under my own category? Might I suggest a Brass sponsorship level?

      Chris Guthrie
      MakeMoneyontheInternet.com

      You know you want to as it would be pretty funny lol. (I’m serious too hah hah :D )
      Chris Guthrie´s last blog ..Make Money with Facebook My ComLuv Profile

      Reply

      Melvin Reply:

      you said you’re serious so i won’t ask if you’re joining.

      Heheh, if you came in earlier, I might have opened the brass level for you but your late. ;-)

      Reply

      Chris Guthrie Reply:

      Damn lol, $20 gift card to open up Brass? In either case I’m glad to see you have a sense of humor.
      Chris Guthrie´s last blog ..May 2010 Income Report My ComLuv Profile

      Reply

    12. elie palima

      - 5th Jun, 10 01:06am

      hello Melvin. the prizes really got me very interested and personally, I think Joining this contest will dramatically improve how I blog. considering I haven’t updated my blog for more than a month, This will be quite a challenge for me.
      elie palima´s last blog ..How to Start a Blog and Make Money Blogging My ComLuv Profile

      Reply

    13. Jaydip Parikh

      - 5th Jun, 10 06:06pm

      Wonderful Contest. I think this will rock the Bloggers. Keep it up buddy.
      Jaydip Parikh´s last blog ..What brokers expect for markets next week? My ComLuv Profile

      Reply

    14. Arafat Hossain Piyada

      - 5th Jun, 10 08:06pm

      Great contest but I always prefer to enter a real money contest. Money can buy things but selling things is hard.
      Arafat Hossain Piyada´s last blog ..How to choose right social network sharing button? My ComLuv Profile

      Reply

      Melvin Reply:

      Yep I understand that. That’s why contests can’t serve everyone.

      Reply

    15. Rajeel

      - 5th Jun, 10 11:06pm

      hi,

      Great contest and great prizes, I wanna participate in it =P

      Reply

    16. David - Finance Blogger

      - 6th Jun, 10 06:06pm

      Sounds really awesome :) . Definitely going to join the twitter contest and see how my luck goes.
      David – Finance Blogger´s last blog ..Book Review: Why Are We So Clueless About The Stock MarketMy ComLuv Profile

      Reply

    17. Adesoji Adegbulu

      - 7th Jun, 10 06:06pm

      Melvin…

      This is really insane. A contest out of the ordinary. Even if I am not moved by the prizes :D , I am moved by the contest itself. This is because, it will help me do what i have not done before. I will also give me the opportunity to help other bloggers…

      Thanks

      Reply

      Melvin Reply:

      yes thanks for the kind words.. :)

      I so much appreciate it.

      Reply

    18. elie palima

      - 9th Jun, 10 02:06am

      hello melvin. Can we submit an entry as a Guest blog???
      elie palima´s last blog ..3 Comment tips That you can do right now to Make your Blog Comments more Cool than others.My ComLuv Profile

      Reply

      Melvin Reply:

      if its that good enough, definitely yes is the answer..

      Reply

      elie palima Reply:

      that’s cool.

      anyways, I was thinking maybe if we could place the “this post is an entry” in the middle of the post?? will that count?
      elie palima´s last blog ..3 Comment tips That you can do right now to Make your Blog Comments more Cool than others.My ComLuv Profile

      Reply

    19. Domain name registration

      - 11th Jun, 10 01:06am

      This is a great contest, I don’t used to participate in contest because of time, I will have create time for this type of contest…

      Reply

    20. Sally

      - 11th Jun, 10 06:06pm

      Hi Melvin,

      OMG so many prizes and such little time!

      Ok, I shall give it a go and hopefully I can sneak a little prize, Sally :)
      Sally´s last blog ..David Walker, Sally’s First Skype Interview…My ComLuv Profile

      Reply

    21. Blogging for Profit

      - 11th Jun, 10 06:06pm

      I received the information Business Advice Forum and thank God that I was a member of it or else I don’t know that you are hosting a contest.

      I will join this contest and hope all the best of creative luck to all the participants including me.

      Ang galing mo Melvin ang Lupit!

      - Felix Albutra
      Blogging for Profit´s last blog ..Links for 2010-06-10 [del.icio.us]My ComLuv Profile

      Reply

    22. Dino Vedo

      - 13th Jun, 10 10:06pm

      great contest looks like a lot of good prizes are at stake!
      Dino Vedo´s last blog ..Taking Baby Steps In The Make Money Online World?My ComLuv Profile

      Reply

    23. KS Chen

      - 14th Jun, 10 07:06am

      I wish to join this contest too although i’m still new in blog marketing! Please count me in! Just retweeted this post. Thanks!
      KS Chen´s last blog ..MyBlog2Day Contest – $800 Cash Prize and Premium Themes GiveawayMy ComLuv Profile

      Reply

    24. R$$sa Mckenzie

      - 15th Jun, 10 03:06pm

      I have never won anything before and I am determine to win one of these fantastic prize pack. It is so good that you are giving everyone the opportunity to take part and win.
      R$$sa Mckenzie´s last blog ..Successful goal setting- the best techniquesMy ComLuv Profile

      Reply

    25. Tinh

      - 16th Jun, 10 10:06am

      Amazing contest indeed. Just know this through your guest post. Thanks Melvin for creating such a wonderful contest with huge list of prize.
      Tinh´s last blog ..How To Double Your Affiliate Commissions Through CJMy ComLuv Profile

      Reply

    26. Shiva | Web Magazine

      - 16th Jun, 10 06:06pm

      Has the contest finished :( I really hope not. Here I have retweeted even if it has finished http://twitter.com/netchunks/status/16297136934

      My bad luck
      Shiva | Web Magazine´s last blog ..How to make a Coupon Website with CouponPress?My ComLuv Profile

      Reply

      Melvin Reply:

      its not yet finished. make sure you do join the main writing contest as well

      Reply

    27. Hannah

      - 16th Jun, 10 07:06pm

      oh wow! Grabe super dami sponsors and prizes! Nice contest Melvin ^_^

      Reply

    28. Latief@AnotherBlogger

      - 1st Jul, 10 09:07pm

      Cool Contest, I’ll try to join ;) may be there’s still time for me :D
      Latief@AnotherBlogger´s last blog ..The Comment Contest End- The Winner IsMy ComLuv Profile

      Reply

    29. Latief@AnotherBlogger

      - 1st Jul, 10 09:07pm

      Cool Contest, I’ll try to join :D
      Latief@AnotherBlogger´s last blog ..The Comment Contest End- The Winner IsMy ComLuv Profile

      Reply

    30. Felix Albutra

      - 3rd Jul, 10 09:07pm

      Hello everyone,

      Count me in… I am also a new contestant of this contest. I hope you benefited from the information being shared in my entry post.

      If you haven’t read my post yet, then you missed something important to learn in your blogging career.

      So, check it out now… And tell me what is your opinion… By the way, congratulations for your new job Melvin. Goodluck pare…

      Thank you for this chance…

      - Felix Albutra
      Felix Albutra´s last blog ..The Ultimate Blog Marketing TechniquesMy ComLuv Profile

      Reply

    31. Shanker Bakshi

      - 6th Jul, 10 01:07am

      I wonder where i was when you were contacting sponsored for this contest, Missed it. Wish to sponsored these sort of contest.
      Shanker Bakshi´s last blog ..How to Get Started in Affiliate Marketing-Part IMy ComLuv Profile

      Reply

    32. d3so

      - 6th Jul, 10 08:07am

      Oh wow, the deadline is going to be here before I know it :P
      I need to get to work.
      d3so´s last blog ..iPhone 4- Thoughts and ConcernsMy ComLuv Profile

      Reply

    33. Lee Ka Hoong

      - 6th Jul, 10 09:07am

      I nearly miss out the contest Melvin! I’ve just retweeted the post and I’m going to write 1-3 blog marketing tips post on my blog as an entry to the contest.

      Regards,
      Lee
      Lee Ka Hoong´s last blog ..How To Market Your Twitter With HummingBirdMy ComLuv Profile

      Reply

    34. Michael Smith

      - 6th Jul, 10 01:07pm

      Thanks for the contest!

      Reply

    35. Felix Albutra

      - 6th Jul, 10 04:07pm

      Wow! This contest will gonna be fun for all contestants. Thanks for this opportunity Melvin and good luck to everybody.
      Felix Albutra´s last blog ..The Ultimate Blog Marketing TechniquesMy ComLuv Profile

      Reply

    36. d3so

      - 12th Jul, 10 05:07am

      I submitted one entry. There’s a few days left, I wonder if I should submit another one…

      Reply

    37. Lee Ka Hoong

      - 13th Jul, 10 10:07am

      Melvin, I’ve just written a blog post as an entry for the contest yesterday. Between, I checked the trackback, you approved a spam site that copied my content, and there is no trackback to my blog post. Kindly check and fix it Melvin.

      http://makemoney.bestmuck.com/.....hat-i-use/

      Thanks,
      Lee
      Lee Ka Hoong´s last blog ..3 Effective Blog Marketing Strategies That I UseMy ComLuv Profile

      Reply

      Felix Albutra Reply:

      Oh… The blog of that guy should be penalized by google.

      I think, all of its post were copied from other blogs. Because I noticed on his archive that he have a lot of articles being published on the same day.

      I guess the blogger of this blog is just trying to spam the entire blogosphere. Why not report this blog? On the other hand, this blog is newly launched.
      Felix Albutra´s last blog ..Blogging Access- My Earnings ReportMy ComLuv Profile

      Reply

    38. omg..found out about it alittle too late… 2 more days to go .. i will be working on it ! ^_^
      Febap Liew | Making Money Online Today´s last blog ..How To Set Up Your Own Internet Business – Part 2My ComLuv Profile

      Reply

    39. Just written a post and posted it phew~ i know a post may eventually get me no where in winning, but I have my fingers cross… besides, the thrill is in participating in itself, ain’t it. its not entirely all about winning. ;)
      cheers
      Febap Liew | Making Money Online Today´s last blog ..Market Your Blog The Way I Did The Art Of ‘Selling’ MoreMy ComLuv Profile

      Reply

    40. Thu Nguyen

      - 15th Jul, 10 02:07am

      Wow, kind of late in the game but hopefully with the 70-30 ratio, at least there’s still a chance. Sounds like some fun. Count me in! Now to get those 5 entries out if I can be tomorrow! :)
      Thu Nguyen´s last blog ..What Your Personal Relationship Can Teach You About Building Your Online Blog Subscription ListMy ComLuv Profile

      Reply

    41. Thu Nguyen

      - 15th Jul, 10 02:07am

      Just realized that there’s a time difference, missed it by 24 hours! Oh well, keeping my fingers crossed for the secret contests :) .
      Thu Nguyen´s last blog ..What Your Personal Relationship Can Teach You About Building Your Online Blog Subscription ListMy ComLuv Profile

      Reply

    42. Cynthia

      - 19th Jul, 10 05:07am

      I added one to the mix – all about being a Name Dropper!
      Cynthia´s last blog ..Better Blogging- Be a Name DropperMy ComLuv Profile

      Reply

    43. Julius

      - 19th Jul, 10 10:07am

      This is a wonderful opportunity, especially for bloggers like me that’s still learning a lot from the filed. I’ll submit an entry now and try to submit others before the contest closes. I don’t know my chance on the quality and popularity aspects, if I have any, but it’s sure looks like fun interacting with the community.

      Keep it up and more power to you!

      Reply

    Trackbacks

    1. Weekend Roundup #86 - 8th Jun, 10 12:06am

    Leave Comment

    (required)

    (required)


    Comments will be closed on July 19, 2011.

    CommentLuv Enabled

  • Recent Readers


  • Friend Me

  • © 2010 MelvinBlog Dot Com. All rights reserved. ColorMatic Theme by Theme Wars created by .