I’m seeing this plugin in LOTS of blogs that I’m reading and commenting to and I wasn’t really that much concerned about it, initially. However when I started commenting again on lots of blogs as part of my back to blogging tasks, I started getting annoyed with this plugin. Why is that so?
Confirm you are not a spammer
What I’m talking about is this plugin called Anti-Spambot created by GrowMap and Andy w/c are people that I know and respect a lot. The way this plugin works is that there’s a checkbox in a comment form and before you can submit your comment, you will need to tick the checkbox to indeed confirm that you are not a spammer. How much sense does that make?
Well its not really that much of a big deal for me actually. I just find that its a workflow killer. I mean, you’re typing comments and doing this and that and when you click submit, you will get this notice that you have to confirm. Not that its annoying but it just gives me the ‘wtf’ look on my face. It doesn’t reload the page either so your comment will still be there but I guess its just human nature to get the ‘what’ look when you submit something and it doesn’t get submitted immediately. lols.
The other side
I haven’t tried the plugin yet so I haven’t had a chance to see what’s behind it yet. However from a bloggers perspective, I can’t really see much the value of it. I mean, what makes it different from a captcha? It requires you to do a thing before submitting your comment. Is it not making it hard for your reader to do commenting? Or maybe its just being lazy to moderate comments all in all?
If you’re reading this blog for a while you know that I value comments a lot and that I make it easy for people to interact (I always ask for their take, whatnot). With that I’m thinking having this ‘confirm you’re not a spammer’ box will only give your readers a step more before they can do what they want to do. And that maybe there’s a conversion part there that gets unconverted instead.
But again that’s just my opinion. Or maybe is there something that I misunderstood with regards to the plugin? Is Akismet not enough?
Popularity: 7% [?]
- Related Posts
Hey Melvin, I just wanted to give you a heads up. The tweetmeme button you are using on your articles at the top left is not sharing your twitter username with the tweet. You’re going to miss out on who is sharing your content unless you modify that.
Daniel Snyder´s last [type] ..Privatize social networking with Glassboard
Reply
Melvin Reply:
September 17th, 2011 at 2:34 pm
Oh thanks Daniel. I thought I already fixed that.
Anyway, I am planning to remove it since its not counting the retweets accurately. I guess I’ll just have to rely on Twitter’s widget itself.
But thanks man!
Reply
Melvin, the plugin you are talking about loads via a javascript hence making it a greater challenge for bots. It is simpler than a captcha which is why it is much more popular. People often get captcha’s wrong and need to retry. Checking a box is one step that most are willing to take. I fail to see your issue with this plugin, it makes a lot more sense than other methods.
Daniel Snyder´s last [type] ..Privatize social networking with Glassboard
Reply
Hi Melvin, from what I’ve seen it works amazing and has 100% stooped all the spam on my blogs. the one issue I’ve seen is if a blog doesn’t support Java pop ups it will actually load a page that says you forgot to check the ox ad at that point your comment is lost. Besides that it’s been a great addition to my blog.
bbrian017´s last [type] ..Are you throwing a contest or giveaway with us?
Reply
Brankica Reply:
September 14th, 2011 at 8:46 am
I can not agree more with Brian.
I have honestly never heard anyone say “what is the point” to that plugin. The point is that it stops hundreds of bot spam comments so I don’t have to spend hours going through them and deleting them.
I have had it on my blog for 9 months now and that is about how long have I been checking the box on other blogs when commenting and I have never forgot to check the box.
I think it can’t even be compared to CAPTCHA because you are clicking on “submit comment” button anyway, so you have the mouse in your hand and it is as easy as it gets. CAPTCHA usually makes me either do the maths or try to decipher weird words.
I have no connection to the plugin or the developers so I have no reason to support it so hard, but I think you should read up on this one and see how it changed blogging for better.
Brankica´s last [type] ..Aweber or MailChimp | Why You Should Choose My New Favorite
Reply
Melvin Reply:
September 17th, 2011 at 2:38 pm
@brian @brankica, noted!
Reply
I personally think the ‘Confirm you are not a spammer’ should be changed into something more suitable for the eyes of the professional blogger and the commentator.
This is, all in all, a great plugin though. =]
Reply
Melvin Reply:
September 25th, 2011 at 1:58 pm
I guess it depends. On a quick look, it seems offending but I don’t think thats a big deal either. Personally that part of text is just fine to me.
Reply
What’s the use? It’s gotten rid of 99% of my spam!
Lisa´s last [type] ..Disney On Ice presents Mickey & Minnie’s Magical Journey
Reply
Well, at first I didn’t believe this plugin is that damn good, but it was introduce at Basic Blog Tips, so I try it and it stop all spam to almost zero and the best part is it make one more step for people to comment.
Why I like to make difficulty for people to comment? Well, the reason is simple, because those that took the step to tick that small box, are actually and more likely to leave a comment that make sense to me rather then a comment that doesn’t give a shit.
If you really look at yourself at ticking the box, don’t you feel that the comment you wrote on that blog post is meant for the author to read, strange but true that when you don’t give a shot to comment, usually when the pop up came up telling you to tick the box, you will feel “ah… forget it” kind of mindset.
TheBadBlogger´s last [type] ..5 Signs to Prove You Are Gonna Suck By the End of 2011!
Reply
Melvin Reply:
September 25th, 2011 at 2:01 pm
Right. I get your point and I think thats a pretty good point. Hmmm, I will definitely give that plugin a good try.
Thanks Wong!
Reply
I’m surprise it works. Any spammer with half a brain can easily bypass Javascript. Just saying.
Rhys´s last [type] ..Services I Use – Bookmarking Demon
Reply
Yea but Rhys spammers dont have half a brain so its not that easy for them
SEOevents´s last [type] ..Thinkvis 6 September 2011
Reply
I think the plugin will prevent a lot of people from leaving comments, and Akismet is enough, since you can’t get comments without any spam.
Reply
Melvin Reply:
September 25th, 2011 at 2:02 pm
Thats one of my points in the article but reading some of the comments, I think I would give the plugin a try.
Doesn’t harm that much to try eh?
Reply
If you have askimet then I don’t see the point. I think it might be an alternative for those that are anti-askimet or use other anit-spam plugins. Some people like askimet and other are against it like the growmap site. I have come across a few other anti-spam plugins that seem better than grow map check this box thing for that matter. I need to test them one day, but haven’t had a chance to do so yet. The one I am looking into as an alternative to askimet is WP-AntiSpam, but so far I haven’t had a chance to spend much time with it.
Ray´s last [type] ..What do you mean it’s a hoax
Reply
I personally think the ‘Confirm you are not a spammer’ should be changed into something more suitable for the eyes of the professional blogger and the commentator.
This is, all in all, a great plugin though. =]
Reply
This plugin has its own pros and cons for a webmaster prospective it significantly decreases the comments, where as a user might end up some frustration when he is see the pop up and at times chances are high that a no vice user might mark up your blog as a spam one..
Raj @ Blogging Tips & Tricks´s last [type] ..Things to Keep in Mind Before Opting For A Web Hosting Company
Reply
I like this plugin. I personally believe it’s much less frustrating then captcha. Especially Recaptcha gives often hard to read pictures.
teen kasia´s last [type] ..Teen Kasia outdoor
Reply
This plugin is really useful! I barley get any spam now days and some great comments so we can discuss on the topic I write.
Mitja@ MW3 Strategy Guide´s last [type] ..Kosh Modern Warfare 3 Strategy Guide Review
Reply
I just encountered this plugin on another site, which immediately caused me to Google it, which in turn lead me here, which at the very least means you got one more visitor to your blog!
I did find it irritating, but now that I’ve read the comments above, I’ve decided it actually seems like a good plugin. I wonder if it works on bbpress? That forum seems incredibly vulnerable to spam.
Yee Mei´s last [type] ..All needs of your baby’s taken care off – Experienced Nanny
Reply
Well this plugin is better than captcha since users don’t need to guess the word, type it, get it wrong and have to redo it again. Whats is this commentluv about?
http://ayumilove.net
Reply